Datomic Compatibility

pg_mentat implements the core Datomic data model and query language as a PostgreSQL extension. This document reflects the actual implementation status of the current codebase.

Overview

pg_mentat provides Datomic-compatible schema, transactions, and Datalog queries via SQL functions. The companion mentatd server exposes an HTTP API compatible with Datomic client libraries.

Transaction Operations

Feature Datomic pg_mentat Status
:db/add Yes Yes Complete
:db/retract Yes Yes Complete
:db/retractEntity Yes Yes Complete – cascade via :db/isComponent
:db.fn/cas Yes Yes Complete – compare-and-swap
with (speculative) Yes Yes Complete – mentat_with()
Map notation Yes Yes Complete
Tempids Yes Yes Complete
Lookup refs Yes Yes Complete
Upsert (unique/identity) Yes Yes Complete
Tx metadata (:db/txInstant) Yes Yes Complete
Negative tempids Yes No N/A – use string tempids
:db/fn (database functions) Yes No Not Planned – security risk

Query Operations

Find Specifications

Feature Datomic pg_mentat Status
Relation [:find ?x ?y] Yes Yes Complete
Collection [:find [?x ...]] Yes Yes Complete
Tuple [:find [?x ?y]] Yes Yes Complete
Scalar [:find ?x .] Yes Yes Complete

Where Clauses

Feature Datomic pg_mentat Status
Basic patterns Yes Yes Complete
NOT clauses Yes Yes Complete – NOT EXISTS subquery
NOT-JOIN Yes Yes Complete
OR clauses Yes Yes Complete – UNION
OR-JOIN Yes Yes Complete

Input Bindings

Feature Datomic pg_mentat Status
Scalar :in ?x Yes Yes Complete
Collection :in [?x ...] Yes Yes Complete
Tuple :in [?x ?y] Yes Yes Complete
Relation :in [[?x ?y]] Yes Yes Complete

Query Functions

Function Datomic pg_mentat Status
get-else Yes Yes Complete – LEFT JOIN + COALESCE
missing? Yes Yes Complete – NOT EXISTS subquery
ground Yes Yes Complete – constant binding
get-some Yes No Not implemented
tuple Yes No Not implemented
untuple Yes No Not implemented

Predicates

Feature Datomic pg_mentat Status
=, != Yes Yes Complete
<, >, <=, >= Yes Yes Complete
Arithmetic (+, -, *, /) Yes Yes Complete
like / ilike N/A Yes Extension – PostgreSQL LIKE/ILIKE
Type-safety guard Yes Yes Complete – mismatched types produce empty set

Aggregates

Aggregate Datomic pg_mentat Status
count Yes Yes Complete
count-distinct Yes Yes Complete
sum Yes Yes Complete
min Yes Yes Complete
max Yes Yes Complete
avg Yes Yes Complete
sample Yes Yes Complete
median Yes No Not implemented
variance Yes No Not implemented
stddev Yes No Not implemented

Rules

Feature Datomic pg_mentat Status
Named rules Yes Yes Complete
Recursive rules Yes Yes Complete – WITH RECURSIVE CTE
Rule sets (multiple heads) Yes Yes Complete
Rules with predicates Yes Yes Complete

Pull API

Feature Datomic pg_mentat Status
Attribute selection Yes Yes Complete
Wildcard [*] Yes Yes Complete
Reverse lookup [:_attr] Yes Yes Complete
Nested/map specs Yes Yes Complete
Recursion {:attr ...} Yes Yes Complete – cycle detection
Bounded recursion {:attr N} Yes Yes Complete
Default values Yes Yes Complete
Rename (:as) Yes Yes Complete
Limit (:limit N) Yes Yes Complete
Component auto-expand Yes Yes Complete
pull-many Yes Yes Complete
Namespace wildcard Yes No Not implemented

Schema

Feature Datomic pg_mentat Status
:db/ident Yes Yes Complete
:db/valueType Yes Yes Complete (9 types)
:db/cardinality Yes Yes Complete (one/many)
:db/unique (value) Yes Yes Complete
:db/unique (identity) Yes Yes Complete + upsert
:db/index Yes Yes Complete
:db/fulltext Yes Yes Complete – BM25 scoring
:db/isComponent Yes Yes Complete – cascade retraction
:db/noHistory Yes Yes Complete
:db/doc Yes Yes Complete
Schema alteration Yes Yes Complete

Value Types

Type Datomic pg_mentat Storage
:db.type/boolean Yes Yes BOOLEAN in datoms_boolean_new
:db.type/long Yes Yes BIGINT in datoms_long_new
:db.type/double Yes Yes DOUBLE PRECISION in datoms_double_new
:db.type/string Yes Yes TEXT in datoms_text_new
:db.type/keyword Yes Yes TEXT in datoms_keyword_new
:db.type/ref Yes Yes BIGINT in datoms_ref_new
:db.type/instant Yes Yes TIMESTAMPTZ in datoms_instant_new
:db.type/uuid Yes Yes UUID in datoms_uuid_new
:db.type/bytes Yes Yes BYTEA in datoms_bytes_new
:db.type/bigint Yes No Not implemented
:db.type/bigdec Yes No Not implemented
:db.type/uri Yes No Not Planned – use string
:db.type/tuple Yes No Not Planned – Datomic Cloud only

Time-Travel

Feature Datomic pg_mentat Status
as-of Yes Yes Complete – mentat_as_of()
since Yes Yes Complete – mentat_since()
history Yes Yes Complete – mentat_history()
tx-range Yes Yes Complete – mentat_tx_range()
Basis-t Yes Yes Complete – MAX(tx) query

Excision

Feature Datomic pg_mentat Status
Entity excision Yes Yes Complete – mentat_excise()
Partition gating Yes Yes Complete – allow_excision flag
Schema protection Yes Yes Complete – entid < 10000 blocked
Dangling ref check Yes Yes Complete
Excision log N/A Yes Extension – audit trail

Subscriptions / tx-report-queue

Feature Datomic pg_mentat Status
tx-report-queue Yes Yes Complete – LISTEN/NOTIFY triggers
Subscribe by query No Yes Extension – mentat_subscribe()
Unsubscribe Yes Yes Complete – mentat_unsubscribe()

mentatd HTTP Protocol

Feature Datomic Client mentatd Status
list-databases Yes Yes Complete
create-database Yes Yes Complete
delete-database Yes Yes Complete
connect Yes Yes Complete
transact Yes Yes Complete
query Yes Yes Complete
pull Yes Yes Complete
entity Yes Yes Complete
EDN serialization Yes Yes Complete
Transit+JSON Yes Yes Complete
CORS N/A Yes Complete
HTTP/2 Yes No Not implemented
Streaming responses Yes No Not implemented

Known Incompatibilities

Feature Reason Workaround
:db/fn Security risk – arbitrary code execution Application logic
Peer mode Architecture incompatible (embedded JVM) Use mentatd HTTP API
Datomic Analytics Proprietary PostgreSQL analytics tools
Negative tempids Not supported Use string tempids
Peer cache No equivalent Application-layer caching

Migration from Datomic

Schema definitions transfer directly. Remove #db/id partition references:

;; Datomic
[{:db/id #db/id[:db.part/db]
  :db/ident :person/name
  :db/valueType :db.type/string
  :db/cardinality :db.cardinality/one
  :db.install/_attribute :db.part/db}]

;; pg_mentat (same minus partition boilerplate)
[{:db/ident :person/name
  :db/valueType :db.type/string
  :db/cardinality :db.cardinality/one}]

Queries work unchanged. Transactions work unchanged. Pull patterns work unchanged.